|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Unintentional Discovery
Dear Steve,
My friend offered to let me practice a power animal retrieval for her. I just did a journey to the upper world to ask my teacher if this was appropriate for her. He said a definite yes and then he showed me some other things about her. My friend has been having a very difficult time connecting with her spirit guide. She so desperately wants to meet him/her/it, and has been trying for some time. One thing that my spirit teacher showed me on this journey was her spirit teacher. Is it appropriate to tell her this, or should she find him in her own time? Could I be meant to tell her to help her?
Nancy
Hi Nancy,
To a thoughtful practitioner, these can be tricky moments. The ethics hangs on a lot of different things. Again, I always believe that the ‘carte blanche’ approach offers a lot of initial room, to then make further determinations, but with less obvious initial constraint.
We have access to lots of information when journeying. If you do not have such pre-permission, it is – ethically speaking – pushing the limits to be looking into other things. It is a little like going into someone’s house and looking for some things for which you have permission to poke around for, and stumbling on a file of other information for which you do not have permission to poke into. Then another family member comes up, and not knowing the limits of your inquiry, seeing your interest, want to be helpful and begin telling you what the files contain. They mean well, but they don’t know the obligations and constraints you are working within.
To keep ourselves from falling into this ethical dilemma, we get an initial carte blanche from our client: “Is it ok if I keep my eyes wide open? If other information is given to me than that about a power animal, can I look into this?” Or else, we have to be very strict and inform the helpful spirits that we, unfortunately, cannot learn about these things at this time. It is a little like being a courtroom and the judge (you) declaring: “Strike this last statement from the record.” It never happened. Both we, and the others who show up, are only approaching this from a well-meaning place, and we only have our client’s best interests. As difficult as it may be, because we are being given information that may be very helpful to a client, we are ethically obligated to tell these people who mean well that these are things we do not have authority to know about.
Yet, all is not lost. I, for one, feel that despite the ethical quandary I feel it is totally appropriate in this case to return and inform the client that I didn’t have permission to inquire but was informed that there is a spirit teacher who is available to the client, without going into details about the teacher, but perhaps telling the client the virtues of having such a teacher. This leave the inquiry open and fresh. Everyone has teachers and spirit helpers. In this case, you are not really providing extra information, but merely have the basic truths of shamanic sensibility validated.
When we retrieve a power animal, we are retrieving a source of power. Yet, the representative of that power (Wolf, Horse, Beaver, etc.) will not necessarily be there for reasons understood in the same way be a practitioner and their client. How I might understand the power of Horse is by no means the same as how Horse is understood by my client. It is up to my client to derive the full meaning and power from the returned spirit helper. I am merely a kind of message-carrier, informing them that Horse is here for them. Perhaps I have been given some clues, such as Horse telling me that he/she is there to bring a ‘bigness of spirit’, or ‘willingness to go long distances’ or ability to ‘carry oneself as well as others’ but this is by no means the limits of that spirit’s power, nor are these reasons for its presence necessarily understood the same way by myself and my client.
There is always the matter that how the spirit teacher was shown to you has every reason to be shown to you in the way you would best understand the teacher… not the way the client would best understand the teacher. The relationship with teachers is potentially far more complex than that with s spirit helper in animal form. As we know from our own experience with teachers, there are aspects of this relationship that are very personal and complex. In the case of teachers, I will always recommend that a client learn now to journey so that they can begin this relationship with their teacher that offers so much growth and understanding, rather than try to achieve such growth through an intermediary such as myself.
So, if a client’s teacher shows herself to me as a very old woman, and yet I tell the client simply that “yes, you have a teacher who wants to help you”, I am truncating the information. Am I therefore ‘lying by omission’? Certainly, I am, if by ‘lying’ we mean not divulging everything we are shown. But I have my good reasons for doing so: for instance, the teacher may not show herself in the same way if my client was to see her, and my report of ‘old’ or even ‘female’ may make it more difficult for the client to recognize or accept her when (hopefully) the client learns to journey and finds her teacher herself. For instance, this teacher you may eventually show itself to your client (when she journeys to meet it) as a young man for all we know. Here, what we understand about the nature of shamanic work helps us find the appropriate things to say, which may not be the entirety of what we were shown.
Some clients do not have the incentive to do this self-work. Yes, we can still journey for our clients, meet their teachers, make inquiry for them, and retrieve answers for them, but this is not nearly so powerful as the direct relationship between a client and their teacher. And, because the teacher is showing in a form that we (not our client) best understands him or her, the image of the teacher may be appropriate for us, but not for the client. Certainly, we can ask this directly… “Are you showing yourself in this form to help me understand you, or is this the form you would show yourself to my client?” and this may clear the matter up to some extent. Yet still, it is the relationship between the teacher and a person that is the key, and for that, the two of them deserve their direct contact themselves.
Then there is the matter of when having information, whether it is in addition to what we went to find out or not, we still don’t automatically ‘blurt all’. This is because we are guided by that which the spirits are not constrained by, which is human ethics. Then, there is the secondary matter of always communicating what we know through compassionate speech. For instance: you are informed that a client’s sickly daughter who has been under medical care will in the future, succumb to the illness. It is not necessary to tell the client this: they are already concerned, treatment is being given, etc. In this case, I would not tell the client what I was told. I would, however, use this information privately to help coax the client and their daughter live the best life that they still have available. I might say something like, “You know, it is interesting, sometimes we get truths in our journeys that really remind us of important things in life. This time, I was reminded how important it is to drink life in fully, and reach within it for all that it has to offer while we have it.” Perhaps the client then becomes worried, thinking about her daughter. Perhaps the client presses me: “Oh dear… did you learn about my daughter? Yes, she is going to get well, isn’t she?” I would not respond with everything I know, but would put what I know into the form that is best for the client and her daughter. Perhaps I would say something like “I don’t know. What I saw was simply a broad truth in life, that we all eventually leave the form we are in today, and I was struck by how important it is for all of us to live life fully today. That is what I know.” There, an underlying goal has been reached: the client under my care (and by extension, her daughter) are better situated to live well, better than how she was when she arrived, and I have been able to use my shamanic work to derive information that can be used to help this client
These are hard, hard choices. You can’t walk away from such instances without discomfort. OK… am I lying? Am I twisting the truth? Certainly. Here is where the world of ethics, compassion, and truth meet. This is one of the most difficult, delicate, and important parts of shamanic work. Compassion and judgment may have priority. These are complex matters, and sometimes, perhaps there is no ’right’ answer, but rather, a ‘best’ answer.
Nancy wrote me back:
As for my friend, I did share the knowledge of the spirit helper with her this morning. I did not go into great detail, but I told her that one is waiting to meet her. I might have given her a little too much information as I told her he presented himself as a monk to me. She told me that this did mean something to her because lately in her meditations, as she is trying to connect with her spirit guide, she has been hearing chanting that reminded her of monks. She naturally pressed me for more details, but I told her that the information may have been given to me in a form that I would best understand and that the best thing for her to do is to meditate and try to connect with her spirit teacher herself. I told her that her spirit guide is waiting to connect with her on a personal level. Tomorrow I am doing a power animal retrieval for her. Maybe this may help empower her to further her experiences and connect with other teachers. I am also encouraging her to read about and try journeying for herself.”
She also said, “You got me thinking in so many ways that now I am careful not to look at or reveal sensitivities that may not be for my knowledge. I also do not want to take away from somebody else’s personal experience. Before your course I would try to help my friends and family interpret messages that they would receive and now I know how mistaken I was. It is their experience to interpret not mine.
Here is part of my response:
“You ask good questions, and these deserve to the looked at closely…”
“I do not think you said too much... In part, this is because of the ring of familiarity with which she responded. You do want to be careful about the differences between what is presented to you and what it is that is meaningful to the client, but you have been proceeding in a very thoughtful and poised way. I think you are doing just fine!”
“Thank you for working so hard. Your clients will appreciate you for this.”
Cultural Theft
"I’m musically talented, a good singer, so that doesn’t bother me. I also know that my soul song doesn’t need to be lyrical.
I grew up around Cherokee Native Americans, and I have heard the songs and chants of the Cherokee for much of my life. I don’t wish to co-opt the “sounds” of Native American singing, without having the actual words, or in such a way that would be disrespectful to them. But, when I try to sing my soul song, it inevitably sounds like Native American dance chants.
I don’t consciously try to mimic any of those songs, and in fact, I feel awkward at how much my soul song sounds like the singing of Cherokee singers at powwows and such as that. But that is how it comes out!
My mother tells me that, far back, there is Cherokee blood in me. My first wife was 1/2 Cherokee, as her parents had moved off the reservation in North Carolina, so my two daughters are 1/4 Cherokee, anyway. My own heritage is more Welsh, Scottish, and English, so I guess I expected to have something less “Indian-sounding,” but that is what seems to come out of me.
Is there a problem with this, other than my own awkwardness? As I said, I have no desire to offend by co-opting the sounds of Native American singing, without knowing the meaning of what I may be singing, although it is probably gibberish.
What does your soul song sound like, Steve? Does it reflect your own personal racial/ethnic heritage, or is it something else entirely?
Tony
Steve: Very good questions!
What does a child start to speak, but the culture in which it finds words to form what it means to express! As much as we are blood-types, we are also culture-types, a combination of ancestral blood and words. Without being restricted, the climate in which we grow up provides innumerable options for expression of one’s self. As we grope for the words, the sounds, the songs, the whatever…, what comes out is formed from all of this.
Remember, you are on a journey back to your true self. Though you are already in yourself, there is likely to be movement back to a purer expression. The steps you take will likely begin closest to where you are standing. Even when we know we can go further, we must begin where we are at. In this case, it is with the forms of expression with which you are most familiar. And, this is the right place to start.
No appropriation of culture here… for you to find fluency in the tones and cadence of native expressions. It is in your immediate cultural influences, perhaps even in your blood itself. There is a tremendous sensitivity around this from both native, and among those sensitive to it, nonnative people, but much of this is missing the issue of what is inherent in all of us: we are a connected people, and live in a cultural milieu. We are all kin and actually quite close, though not often willing to see this or admit it.
It may very well be that as you explore more, that you will find ways of expressing yourself in expressions that predate or geographically distant from American Native expressions. For now, however, you have the language you have. It belongs to you as much as anyone, when you know it is true to you.
And this is the crux of it. If it does not feel true, the dissonance is what is coaxing you back further, perhaps to a form of expression that sometimes may be more primal. A howl, a squeal, a chuckle, bursting, screaming, humming, hiccupping… low to high, high to low. Perhaps it is chest thumping, ground stomping, knee slapping, whistling… These are often either complete forms, or interjections into the soul songs I hear sung. Whatever it is that is expressed, the object is to let it come from as deep a place inside as possible: not in a visceral sense, but in a ‘who I am’ sense.
My own soul song has changed over the years, as I have journeyed closer, or more distant from my true self. It is a returning path, and the expression that comes forth when we open our mouth to sing this song will reflect this
It is who you are who sings, and who you want to let free. Your true self. Keep playing with this, and allow yourself to grope your way towards this. Your instincts will guide you correctly! Plus, you now have a Spirit Helper. Ask him to sing his soul song. Watch and learn!
'Bone Clogging'
I feel that within that calmness and quiet is where I become the hollow bone. It actually does feel literally like space is being created within my being. It is not all gunked up with petty human concerns, but an available space for healing.
Charlene
Steve: Excellent! Yes, it is getting ourselves out of the way so that the spirit-half of the team can do their work. People and the spirit world are powerful in different areas. We humans have our capability in ordinary reality, and the spirits theirs, in non-ordinary reality. We share a job together, merging skills such that the spirits’ power of the healing or divination can come through our body.
Human concerns are legitimate, actually, highly important, even if some sometimes seem trite. However, it is not that spirit-concerns are more important than people-concerns, but that when it comes to serving as a vehicle for healing or divination, that some concerns will be certain to interfere with the healing or divination itself.
Let’s look at concerns as if they were in two tiers. First, there are the toxic concerns that we can be sure some practitioners have had, like “wow… I am a great shaman, let’s make sure they see me as such” or “I wonder if they will pay me more if I find something out about such and such”. These kinds of practitioner concerns are likely to lose the respect of the spirit helpers, and such spirits will soon jettison the practitioner who works along these lines.
The second tier of practitioner concerns would probably cause good work to stumble, but are not as devastatingly toxic as those in the first tier. These might be such concerns as “Oh dear, I better speed up this soul retrieval because I have to go pick up my daughter from school” or “My intention for this journey is to – geeze, am I hungry. A hamburger sure sounds good – oh where was I?… My intention for this journey is to go to the upper world and learn…” The compassionate upper and lower world spirits will probably shake their heads and work with such a practitioner, but with stuff like this going on inside, the ‘hollow bone’ isn’t really so hollow. OK, its not filled up with something toxic to shamanic practice, but these 'second tier' matters will still interfere enough in the clarity of the practice such that the practitioner is unlikely to be as reliable or effective in their work.
As you so rightly say, we can think of the practitioner's 'hollow bone' as ‘space’ being opened up inside us. What can clutter us up is isn’t all toxic, although as ‘gunk’, thoughts of a tasty hamburger, for instance, will certainly interfere with the work of the spirits who work through us!
You know, I'm not so sure a spiritual concern is any more imporant than a human one. Although I don't think you meant it as such, I would like to underscore that human concerns, when compared with spiritual ones, are not necessarily petty. I think we have a subtle (or not so subtle) propensity to elevate spiritual concerns above human ones, and without delving into it deeply, this is in all likelihood a leftover from several thousands of years of religions that minimized or flattened human value and heightened that which was non-Earthly.
Recognition of the Earth-centered sacred, from which shamanic practice is largely if not entirely derived, maintains a respect, appreciation, and awe in the face of all of life… including that of the human being!
share with a friend